Skip to main content

The smallest state has the biggest blockchain ambitions

How the next wave of technology is upending the global economy and its power structures
Feb 09, 2023 View in browser
 
POLITICO's Digital Future Daily newsletter logo

By Ben Schreckinger

U.S. Secretary of Commerce Gina Raimondo.

U.S. Secretary of Commerce Gina Raimondo. | Tasos Katopodis/Getty Images

Crypto is supposed to be exciting, right? Hacking, fraud, overnight billionaires, international fugitives.

Sure. But, far from the high drama of crypto finance, governments around the world have been quietly putting blockchains to a more, well, boring use: recordkeeping.

Though these experiments lack the drama of crypto finance, they do convert on a promise of blockchain technology: that it creates a durable and transparent distributed record of activity. And they raise the prospect that blockchains may soon be coming not just for your wallet, but most other aspects of your life that the state takes an interest in, like birth, death, marriage, and your very identity.

Already, New York City, Chicago’s Cook County, and South Burlington, Vermont, have all explored or deployed programs to put property records on blockchains. California is moving to put car title records on-chain. And if you can’t quite remember whether you really got hitched in Reno last weekend, Washoe County, Nevada, will verify your marriage certificate online using a blockchain.

Much of the experimentation is overseas: National governments in Honduras, Ghana, and Georgia, have pursued blockchain based systems for property records, in addition to local projects in places like El Salvador.

The biggest plans for putting government on-chain in the U.S., though, may be the ones taking shape in its smallest state.

Rhode Island’s Department of Commerce is currently looking for vendors to help it integrate records from agencies across state government into a single blockchain-based system. The hope is that it will make it drastically easier to register a business — a task that currently requires dealing with many different agencies running their own siloed systems.

Unlike its more exotic crypto-finance cousins, this blockchain system was designed to be “boring and not risky,” says Commerce Secretary Elizabeth Tanner, who tells DFD that opening a restaurant in Rhode Island currently requires accessing 11 state websites.

Tanner determined that the use of a distributed blockchain database was the best way to create a single records system used by multiple agencies.

To keep things as boring as humanly possible, she enlisted both Rhode Island’s Division of Motor Vehicles and the state’s certified public accountants for a proof-of-concept pilot program that concluded in June.

The accountants were able to get a digital ID card from the DMV, then use the digital credential to prove their identity to the Department of Business Regulation, which in turn issued them a digital copy of their CPA license.

One issue with blockchains is that they’re designed to be accessed by several parties — sometimes millions, in the case of public chains — meaning that they’re not a good place to store sensitive information in an unencrypted form.

In Rhode Island’s model, most information is stored privately by the government and in users’ digital wallet apps, while the shared blockchain stores public keys — published by the issuing agency — that can be used to verify the authenticity of a user’s digital credentials.

Tanner said she became interested in blockchains about five years ago, when she was serving as the director of the Department of Business Regulation. After dealing with the hassles of opening businesses as an attorney in private practice, she wanted to create a more user-friendly experience for Ocean State entrepreneurs.

Tanner said she quickly discovered that the systems used by other U.S. states were just as clunky as Rhode Island’s. She looked further afield and became enamored of the high-tech approach of the tiny Baltic nation of Estonia, which first began putting government records on a blockchain in 2012.

Tanner credited then-Gov. Gina Raimondo, now the U.S. commerce secretary, with greenlighting the project early on.

Of course, there's a reputational issue. Government recordkeeping requires bedrock public trust, and the meltdown in crypto financial markets has created a serious political liability for projects like Tanner's by tainting the underlying technology in the public imagination.

“It’s becoming a big problem for me,” Tanner said. “I rarely use the word blockchain anymore.” Tanner said she takes special care in describing the project to legislators, who oversee the project’s funding. 

In the course of our conversation, Tanner dropped the less polarizing term “DLT,” an abbreviation of “digital ledger technology.” This broader concept refers to a set of methods for distributed record-keeping that includes blockchains as well as other techniques — including some employed by central bank digital currency experiments — that do not require sequential blocks of data.

The project puts Rhode Island in league with a constellation of other technophile governments. Tanner said she is keeping tabs on initiatives as far afield as Dubai, Singapore and Lichtenstein. In October, she traveled to Estonia to learn more about systems there, and she keeps in touch with the governments of Aruba, Ontario and British Columbia about their own blockchain forays.

For now, the state is fielding an avalanche of questions from potential service providers trying to wrap their heads around the project: Tanner said she hopes to settle on a vendor by the beginning of May. In the meantime, any crypto firms in need of emergency audits know where they can find a group of accountants who have used a blockchain.

 

STEP INSIDE THE WEST WING: What's really happening in West Wing offices? Find out who's up, who's down, and who really has the president’s ear in our West Wing Playbook newsletter, the insider's guide to the Biden White House and Cabinet. For buzzy nuggets and details that you won't find anywhere else, subscribe today.

 
 
METABIRKINS AND THE ANDY WARHOL CONNECTION

Digital artist Mason Rothschild— creator of the “MetaBirkin” NFT handbag — yesterday emerged the loser in a trademark lawsuit initiated by luxury fashion brand Hermès — the real-world manufacturers of Birkin handbags. The case was being watched carefully as a litmus test on an issue very important to the metaverse as it develops: how protections under existing U.S. laws on intellectual property, trademark and copyright would extend into the virtual world.

Brand owners can breathe a sigh of relief for now: a Manhattan jury decided that Rothschild’s “MetaBirkins” were violating Hermès’ trademark rights and ordered him to pay the company $133,000 in damages for trademark infringement, dilution and “cybersquatting.” (Rothschild has indicated he will appeal.)

The verdict shows that “you can extend physical brick-and-mortar IP protection” that apply to physical goods “to the same types of items, albeit pixelated, in the virtual world,” said Preetha Chakrabart, an IP lawyer at the corporate firm Crowell & Moring.

Still, updating IP protections to keep up with technology remains an active task, Chakrabarti said, pointing to the U.S. Copyright and the U.S. Patent and Trademark Offices’ joint study on NFT tokens as one such effort on the federal level.

And questions around metaverse commerce aren’t quite settled yet. There’s a pending Supreme Court case between the Andy Warhol Foundation for the Visual Arts and American photographer Lynn Goldsmith which will decide what qualifies as “transformative fair use” under U.S. copyright law. That case deals with whether Andy Warhol’s silk-screen renderings of the musician Prince, which were based on a photograph that Goldsmith took, violated Goldsmith’s copyright claims over the original photo. The transferable concept here is that if Warhol’s work counts as transformative fair use, so might some NFTs.

Rothschild’s legal team had, in fact, attempted to draw a comparison between the MetaBirkins and Andy Warhol’s widely recognizable “Business Art” project, though Hermès pushed back and District Court Judge Rakoff ultimately ruled against allowing testimony from a Warhol biographer who could make that analogy. —Mohar Chatterjee

RUSSIAN DISINFO: TELEGRAM NOT TWITTER

A close-up view of the Telegram messaging app on a smart phone.

A close-up view of the Telegram messaging app on a smart phone. | Carl Court/Getty Images

Russian disinformation isn’t gone. It’s just moving. With the Kremlin largely deprived of the megaphones that are Twitter, Youtube and Facebook — which have become more alert to Russian propaganda — Telegram has become the new information battleground for the Kremlin, researcher Nika Aleksejeva told Politico’s Mark Scott in today’s Digital Bridge newsletter.

Only last week, threat intelligence firm Logically published a report on two new influence operations “aiming to spread pro-Russian sentiment,” spearheaded by Kremlin-tied propagandists, Luc Michel and Ramzu Yunus. Both influence operations have a strong presence on Telegram, according to the report.

Between EU sanctions on Russian state media, tech companies’ efforts to clamp down on misinformation on their platforms and everyday Ukrainians posting the real-time footage of the war, the Kremlin’s military aggression has not won hearts. But moving to Telegram allows the Kremlin to target “specific pro-Russian online voices versus previous attempts to bombard anyone who would listen to Russian disinformation,” Scott wrote. —Mohar Chatterjee

Tweet of the Day

Tweet from Washington State Department of Natural Resources on Twitter being down.

@waDNR on Twitter

The Future in 5 Links

Stay in touch with the whole team: Ben Schreckinger (bschreckinger@politico.com); Derek Robertson (drobertson@politico.com); Mohar Chatterjee (mchatterjee@politico.com); Steve Heuser (sheuser@politico.com); and Benton Ives (bives@politico.com). Follow us @DigitalFuture on Twitter.

If you’ve had this newsletter forwarded to you, you can sign up and read our mission statement at the links provided.

 

DOWNLOAD THE POLITICO MOBILE APP: Stay up to speed with the newly updated POLITICO mobile app, featuring timely political news, insights and analysis from the best journalists in the business. The sleek and navigable design offers a convenient way to access POLITICO's scoops and groundbreaking reporting. Don’t miss out on the app you can rely on for the news you need, reimagined. DOWNLOAD FOR iOS– DOWNLOAD FOR ANDROID.

 
 
 

Follow us on Twitter

Ben Schreckinger @SchreckReports

Derek Robertson @afternoondelete

Steve Heuser @sfheuser

Benton Ives @BentonIves

 

Follow us

Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Instagram Listen on Apple Podcast
 

To change your alert settings, please log in at https://www.politico.com/_login?base=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.politico.com/settings

This email was sent to rouf@idiot.cloudns.cc by: POLITICO, LLC 1000 Wilson Blvd. Arlington, VA, 22209, USA

Please click here and follow the steps to unsubscribe.

Comments

Popular Posts

📄 Liaqat Ali Ali shared Waheed Zaman's post

  See the post that he shared.           Facebook                 📄 Liaqat Ali Ali shared Waheed Zaman 's post. 26 April at 12:09   View               This message was sent to ludomallam@idiot.cloudns.cc . If you don't want to receive these emails from Facebook in the future, please unsubscribe . Facebook, Inc., Attention: Community Support, 1 Facebook Way, Menlo Park, CA 94025         To help keep your account secure, please don't forward this email. Learn more      

📄 Sazzad Khan shared Shakil Khan's post

  Ludo, see the post that he shared.           Facebook                 📄 Sazzad Khan shared Shakil Khan 's post. 27 April at 21:42   View               This message was sent to ludomallam@idiot.cloudns.cc . If you don't want to receive these emails from Facebook in the future, please unsubscribe . Facebook, Inc., Attention: Community Support, 1 Facebook Way, Menlo Park, CA 94025         To help keep your account secure, please don't forward this email. Learn more      

Afjal Hossain wants to be friends on Facebook

  1 mutual friend - Works at won businass - Atrai, Rājshāhi, Bangladesh - 3,883 friends - 6 photos - 3 groups           Facebook             Afjal Hossain wants to be friends with you on Facebook.   Afjal Hossain Works at won businass · Atrai, Rājshāhi, Bangladesh 1 mutual friend · 3,883 friends · 6 photos · 3 groups               Confirm request     See all requests             This message was sent to ludomallam@idiot.cloudns.cc . If you don't want to receive these emails from Facebook in the future, please unsubscribe . Facebook, Inc., Attention: Community Support, 1 Facebook Way, Menlo Park, CA 94025         To help keep your account secure, please don't forward this email. Learn more.      

DeepMind Gemini AI could rival ChatGPT / Congress restricts ChatGPT use / Unity launches AI marketplace

Plus: C-suite leaders plan to hire due to generative AI Inside AI For June 27, 2023 Thank you to our sponsor Hey Insiders,  Welcome to Inside AI! Here are today's top stories: Google DeepMind is developing a Gemini chatbot to rival ChatGPT. 64% of C-suite leaders say they plan to increase hiring due to generative AI. U.S. House members were instructed to limit ChatGPT usage to the paid version. Scroll down for some quick hits, and then let us know what other content you'd like to see in future issues!  Beth p/beth-duckett 1 Google DeepMind, its AI research lab, is developing a new chatbot called Gemini that could rival or surpass OpenAI's ChatGPT, according to CEO Demis Hassabis. Gemini, built on the capabilities of DeepMind's AlphaGo AI system, could analyze text, plan, and solve problems, Hassabis told Wired. More: AlphaGo is DeepMind's AI system that defeated a professional human player i...

The $975 million TikTok mystery

Red flags pile up in Khaby Lame’s mega deal. View in browser | Subscribe ...

Breaking News: Dems fall short of flipping deep-red House seat in surprisingly competitive Tennessee special election

Dems fall short of flipping deep-red House seat in surprisingly competitive Tennessee special election Breaking News Alert ...

Start separating your leaves from your trash

Presented by Uber: POLITICO's must-read briefing informing the daily conversation among knowledgeable New Yorkers May 31, 2023 View in browser   By Danielle Muoio Dunn and Zachary Schermele Presented by ...

Meta removes disinformation campaigns / Google Maps disables features in Ukraine / NIO seeks HK listing

Plus: OnePlus's upcoming phone can fully charge in 15 minutes. Inside.com Part of   Network February 28, 2022 Presented by Facebook parent company Meta said it took down two disinformation campaigns that targeted Ukraine and were spreading anti-Ukrainian propaganda. Russia-linked hacking group Ghostwriter, which perpetrated one of the campaigns, gained access to real Facebook accounts and posted YouTube videos "portraying Ukrainian troops as weak and surrendering to Russia," according to Meta. The company said it blocked phishing domains that Ghostwriter used to gain access to the accounts and beefed up security. More: Meta described the second disinformation campaign as "coordinated inauthentic behavior" made up of about 40 accounts, pages, and groups on Facebook and Instagram.  The campaign ran several websites disguised as independent...

The 2021 Holiday Magic Gift Guide + $610 in free gifts

The response to our Black Friday Sale  has already been overwhelming (over $600 in free magic), but I've gotten a ton of emails asking my advice on what to buy. So here's a list of my personal hand-picked recommendations . Whether you're buying these for yourself or someone else, they're all excellent, and get my highest recommendations. The 2021 Penguin Magic Holiday Gift Guide (organized by category) Gingerbread Playing Cards: A very limited 2021 edition holiday deck of playing cards. Free with every order o...

Only 12 hours left to get over $600 in free magic. Black Friday ends at midnight!

At midnight tonight, our Black Friday sale disappears! For the next 12 hours, every order gets a free trick , STAB by Luke Jermay , an incredible display of skill you need to know....

Popular Posts

📄 Liaqat Ali Ali shared Waheed Zaman's post

  See the post that he shared.           Facebook                 📄 Liaqat Ali Ali shared Waheed Zaman 's post. 26 April at 12:09   View               This message was sent to ludomallam@idiot.cloudns.cc . If you don't want to receive these emails from Facebook in the future, please unsubscribe . Facebook, Inc., Attention: Community Support, 1 Facebook Way, Menlo Park, CA 94025         To help keep your account secure, please don't forward this email. Learn more      

📄 Sazzad Khan shared Shakil Khan's post

  Ludo, see the post that he shared.           Facebook                 📄 Sazzad Khan shared Shakil Khan 's post. 27 April at 21:42   View               This message was sent to ludomallam@idiot.cloudns.cc . If you don't want to receive these emails from Facebook in the future, please unsubscribe . Facebook, Inc., Attention: Community Support, 1 Facebook Way, Menlo Park, CA 94025         To help keep your account secure, please don't forward this email. Learn more      

Afjal Hossain wants to be friends on Facebook

  1 mutual friend - Works at won businass - Atrai, Rājshāhi, Bangladesh - 3,883 friends - 6 photos - 3 groups           Facebook             Afjal Hossain wants to be friends with you on Facebook.   Afjal Hossain Works at won businass · Atrai, Rājshāhi, Bangladesh 1 mutual friend · 3,883 friends · 6 photos · 3 groups               Confirm request     See all requests             This message was sent to ludomallam@idiot.cloudns.cc . If you don't want to receive these emails from Facebook in the future, please unsubscribe . Facebook, Inc., Attention: Community Support, 1 Facebook Way, Menlo Park, CA 94025         To help keep your account secure, please don't forward this email. Learn more.      

DeepMind Gemini AI could rival ChatGPT / Congress restricts ChatGPT use / Unity launches AI marketplace

Plus: C-suite leaders plan to hire due to generative AI Inside AI For June 27, 2023 Thank you to our sponsor Hey Insiders,  Welcome to Inside AI! Here are today's top stories: Google DeepMind is developing a Gemini chatbot to rival ChatGPT. 64% of C-suite leaders say they plan to increase hiring due to generative AI. U.S. House members were instructed to limit ChatGPT usage to the paid version. Scroll down for some quick hits, and then let us know what other content you'd like to see in future issues!  Beth p/beth-duckett 1 Google DeepMind, its AI research lab, is developing a new chatbot called Gemini that could rival or surpass OpenAI's ChatGPT, according to CEO Demis Hassabis. Gemini, built on the capabilities of DeepMind's AlphaGo AI system, could analyze text, plan, and solve problems, Hassabis told Wired. More: AlphaGo is DeepMind's AI system that defeated a professional human player i...

The $975 million TikTok mystery

Red flags pile up in Khaby Lame’s mega deal. View in browser | Subscribe ...

Breaking News: Dems fall short of flipping deep-red House seat in surprisingly competitive Tennessee special election

Dems fall short of flipping deep-red House seat in surprisingly competitive Tennessee special election Breaking News Alert ...

Start separating your leaves from your trash

Presented by Uber: POLITICO's must-read briefing informing the daily conversation among knowledgeable New Yorkers May 31, 2023 View in browser   By Danielle Muoio Dunn and Zachary Schermele Presented by ...

Meta removes disinformation campaigns / Google Maps disables features in Ukraine / NIO seeks HK listing

Plus: OnePlus's upcoming phone can fully charge in 15 minutes. Inside.com Part of   Network February 28, 2022 Presented by Facebook parent company Meta said it took down two disinformation campaigns that targeted Ukraine and were spreading anti-Ukrainian propaganda. Russia-linked hacking group Ghostwriter, which perpetrated one of the campaigns, gained access to real Facebook accounts and posted YouTube videos "portraying Ukrainian troops as weak and surrendering to Russia," according to Meta. The company said it blocked phishing domains that Ghostwriter used to gain access to the accounts and beefed up security. More: Meta described the second disinformation campaign as "coordinated inauthentic behavior" made up of about 40 accounts, pages, and groups on Facebook and Instagram.  The campaign ran several websites disguised as independent...

The 2021 Holiday Magic Gift Guide + $610 in free gifts

The response to our Black Friday Sale  has already been overwhelming (over $600 in free magic), but I've gotten a ton of emails asking my advice on what to buy. So here's a list of my personal hand-picked recommendations . Whether you're buying these for yourself or someone else, they're all excellent, and get my highest recommendations. The 2021 Penguin Magic Holiday Gift Guide (organized by category) Gingerbread Playing Cards: A very limited 2021 edition holiday deck of playing cards. Free with every order o...

Only 12 hours left to get over $600 in free magic. Black Friday ends at midnight!

At midnight tonight, our Black Friday sale disappears! For the next 12 hours, every order gets a free trick , STAB by Luke Jermay , an incredible display of skill you need to know....

Archive

Show more

Bottom Widget

Bottom Widget

font.css

videocontrol.css

GitFootCSS

BottomEdge Widget Title

Copyright © 2023 IdiotMail