Skip to main content

The doctor is AI

How the next wave of technology is upending the global economy and its power structures
Apr 27, 2023 View in browser
 
POLITICO's Digital Future Daily newsletter logo

By Ben Leonard

With help from Derek Robertson

The Cleveland Clinic is pictured. | Getty

The Cleveland Clinic.

This week, Digital Future Daily is focusing on the fast-moving landscape of generative AI and the conversation about how and whether to regulate it — from pop culture to China to the U.S. Congress. Read day one's coverage on AI havoc in the music business, day two on AI inventors, and day three on a proposed revolution in data rights.

The chatbot is here to see you.

That’s what many health care organizations envision in the future. As workforce shortages plague the health care sector, executives and tech companies are looking for ways to boost efficiency and let providers spend more time with patients and less time in their digital systems.

Generative artificial intelligence is one potential way to do that, by allowing chatbots to answer the kinds of health care questions that often leave doctors’ inboxes overflowing.

Right now, no fewer than half of health care organizations are planning to use some kind of generative AI pilot program this year, according to a recent report by consulting firm Accenture. Some could involve patients directly. AI could make it easier for patients to understand a providers’ note, or listen to visits and summarize them.

But what about… you know, actual doctoring? So far, in limited research, chatbots have proven decent at asking simple health questions. Researchers from Cleveland Clinic and Stanford recently asked ChatGPT 25 questions on heart disease prevention. Its responses were appropriate for 21 of 25, including on how to lose weight and reduce cholesterol.

But it stumbled on more nuanced questions, including in one instance “firmly recommending” cardio and weightlifting, which could be dangerous for some patients.

Steven Lin, a physician and executive director of the Stanford Healthcare AI Applied Research Team, said that the models are fairly solid at getting things like medical school test questions right. However, in the real world, questions from patients are often messy and incomplete, Lin said, unlike the structured questions on exams.

“Real patient cases do not fit into the oversimplified ‘textbook’ presentations that LLMs are trained on,” Lin told Digital Future Daily. “The best questions for LLMs like ChatGPT are those with clear, evidence-based, widely established, and rarely disputed answers that apply universally, such as ‘What are the most common side effects of medication X?’”

Lin is skeptical that generative AI will quickly become widespread in frontline health care. He pointed out that electronic health records systems were first rolled out in the 1960s, but it took until the 2010s to become ubiquitous.

“Soon, in the next 6-12 months, the hype will cool down and we'll slow down and realize how much work still needs to be done,” Lin said.

Brian Anderson, chief digital health physician at MITRE, a nonprofit that helps manage federal science research, sees it moving quite a bit faster — becoming widespread in the sector within a year or two, given the business proposition to allow providers to be more efficient.

“Algorithms... will help drive improved clinical outcomes in the near term," Anderson said. "The comput[ing] power is there to really drive some of the value … it’s just a matter of time.”

The potential for explosive growth is exactly what worries a lot of people about generative AI: They see a highly disruptive and unaccountable new tech platform, still largely experimental, with nearly no brakes on its adoption across society.

Healthcare, though, is a little different. It’s a highly regulated space with a much slower pace of innovation, big liability risks when things go wrong and a lot of existing protections around individual data.

To help users determine if a model is appropriate for them, the Department of Health and Human Services earlier this month proposed new rules that would require makers of AI in healthcare — as well as health technology developers that incorporate other companies' AI — to open up those algorithms to scrutiny if they want HHS’ certification.

That health IT certification for software like electronic health records systems is voluntary, but is required when the technology is used in many government and private health care settings.

Micky Tripathi, HHS’ national coordinator for health IT, understands why the industry is excited about AI’s potential to help better inform care — but also said that the anxiety surrounding generative AI in the wider economy also applies to healthcare.

He didn’t mince words at a recent industry conference: People should have “tremendous fear” about potential safety, quality and transparency issues.

With that in mind, both tech companies and health systems are calling for steps to ensure trust in the technology, and have formed groups to address the issues.

The Coalition for Health AI, whose members include Anderson’s MITRE, Google, Microsoft, Stanford and John Hopkins, recently released a blueprint to facilitate trust in artificial intelligence’s use in health care. It called for any algorithms used in the treatment of disease to be testable, safe, transparent, and explainable, and for software developers to take steps to mitigate bias and protect privacy.

Anderson said he's excited about the technology's potential but is "nervous" about potential future capabilities that can be difficult to anticipate. He said physician inbox management and aiding with drafting letters could be strong early use cases.

“I'm hopeful those are some of the first areas of exploration, rather than helping me decide what to do with this patient that's suffering from some kind of acute sepsis,” Anderson said.

 

GO INSIDE THE 2023 MILKEN INSTITUTE GLOBAL CONFERENCE: POLITICO is proud to partner with the Milken Institute to produce a special edition "Global Insider" newsletter featuring exclusive coverage, insider nuggets and unparalleled insights from the 2023 Global Conference, which will convene leaders in health, finance, politics, philanthropy and entertainment from April 30-May 3. This year’s theme, Advancing a Thriving World, will challenge and inspire attendees to lean into building an optimistic coalition capable of tackling the issues and inequities we collectively face. Don’t miss a thing — subscribe today for a front row seat.

 
 
have compute, will travel

In the race for AI supremacy, it might not be computing firepower that gives researchers a leg up.

In a study published today by Georgetown University’s Center for Security and Emerging Technology, the authors set out to learn more about how “compute” (the term of art for computing power) factors into researchers’ concerns around AI development. The answer? Not as much as you might think.

“More respondents report talent as an important factor for project success, a higher priority with more funding, and a more limiting factor when deciding what projects to pursue,” they write in the paper’s introduction, hence its title: “The Main Resource Is The Human.” Remarkably, this finding mostly held true across both private industry and academia, something the CSET researchers say indicates that policymakers’ focus on semiconductor manufacturing and competition with China might be misguided.

“In light of these results… this report suggests that policymakers temper their expectations regarding the impact that restrictive policies may have on computing resources, and that policymakers instead direct their efforts at other bottlenecks such as developing, attracting, and retaining talent,” the researchers write. — Derek Robertson

wrapping up the eu's metaverse panel

The European Commission concluded its first ever citizens’ panel on the metaverse this week — which produced some notable, if vague, policy recommendations.

Patrick Grady, a policy analyst at the Center For Data Innovation, has been chronicling the three-part citizens’ panel at his blog, and had a concluding recap this morning. Near the end he makes a notable observation: That citizens’ main concerns about the metaverse appear to be around accessibility and privacy, while the Commission’s own consultation appears to be focused on competition and industrial policy.

The panel’s top five priorities, in descending order, were to: “Provide training programs to teachers” on VR technology; to establish clear regulation around anonymity; to “guarantee for all citizens free and easy access” to information about VR; to research its impact on health; and to establish “terms and conditions” for data access and privacy in virtual worlds. The European Union will soon publish its own report on the panel, ahead of the Commission’s wider guidance for the technology now expected in June. — Derek Robertson

Tweet of the Day

I gave GPT-4 eyes.Here’s what I did:- added some data to a vision model- gave the AI camera access- asked it questions about the scene- it identified objects- it searched web for info- used that info to accurately answerWatch it get 3 questions 100% correct!

the future in 5 links

Stay in touch with the whole team: Ben Schreckinger (bschreckinger@politico.com); Derek Robertson (drobertson@politico.com); Mohar Chatterjee (mchatterjee@politico.com); Steve Heuser (sheuser@politico.com); and Benton Ives (bives@politico.com). Follow us @DigitalFuture on Twitter.

If you’ve had this newsletter forwarded to you, you can sign up and read our mission statement at the links provided.

 

GET READY FOR GLOBAL TECH DAY: Join POLITICO Live as we launch our first Global Tech Day alongside London Tech Week on Thursday, June 15. Register now for continuing updates and to be a part of this momentous and program-packed day! From the blockchain, to AI, and autonomous vehicles, technology is changing how power is exercised around the world, so who will write the rules? REGSITER HERE.

 
 
 

Follow us on Twitter

Ben Schreckinger @SchreckReports

Derek Robertson @afternoondelete

Steve Heuser @sfheuser

Benton Ives @BentonIves

 

Follow us

Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Instagram Listen on Apple Podcast
 

To change your alert settings, please log in at https://www.politico.com/_login?base=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.politico.com/settings

This email was sent to rouf@idiot.cloudns.cc by: POLITICO, LLC 1000 Wilson Blvd. Arlington, VA, 22209, USA

Please click here and follow the steps to unsubscribe.

Comments

Popular Posts

💡The most innovative iPhone trick of the year.

Watch the performance: The ULTIMATE every-day carry. Make the physical light on the back of your iPhone come to life and move around. Then hand everything out for examination. This is a wildly innovative idea you have to see to believe.   ...

"Ingenious. Spectators can't reverse engineer it" -Doug Henderson

"I'm doing this first thing in the morning at work, they'll be spitting coffee through their noses, how freaking simply and clever...." - Jeff Thornley https://www.penguinmagic.com/p/7311 Dan Harlan fooled Penn & Teller on national TV recently, and we're proud to present his reputation making mind-reading effect "All Seeing Eye". A masterpiece that will fool everyone you show. Rave reviews have been pouring in since it came out. It's one of the most highly rated tricks on the site.. ...

HHS to doctors: Share patient info or else

Presented by Optum Rx: Delivered daily by 10 a.m., Pulse examines the latest news in health care politics and policy. Oct 31, 2023 View in browser   By Chelsea Cirruzzo and Ben Leonard Presented by ...

"A mind-reading MASTERPIECE."

Watch a full performance here: https://www.penguinmagic.com/p/4760 This is the kind of trick you end your show with. It's that good. Two spectators each think of a name, or a place.   They don't even tell each other what they're thinking!   And yet you are able to read their thoughts through sheer mind-power. "One of my strongest effects of the last 30 years" - Bob Cassidy This was the great Bob Cassidy's signature effect.  A flash of brilliance so inspired, that it can turn anyone into a master...

Google Alert - Swift

Swift Daily update ⋅ November 30, 2017 NEWS Taylor Swift And Ray Charles Are Now Tied With The Same Number Of Hit Singles Forbes TOPSHOT - Singer Taylor Swift performs during the 58th Annual Grammy music Awards in Los Angeles February 15, 2016. (ROBYN BECK/AFP/Getty ... Taylor Swift Adds Tour Dates to Meet Demand - Amplify Taylor Swift Scores First Hot Country Songs Hit Since 2013 With 'New Year's Day' - Billboard Taylor Swift adds tour dates, with one more announced for the South - The State Full Coverage Flag as irrelevant Swift and producers display different ideas of 'new Taylor' on 'Reputation' The Weekender With tracks produced by the team of Max Martin and Shellback, and Jack Antonoff, Taylor Swift shows shades of greatness on 'Reputation,' but fails to ... Taylor Swift Adds 9 Dat...

Breaking News: Top lawmakers strike funding deal, potentially averting weekend shutdown

Breaking News Alert Top lawmakers strike funding deal, potentially averting week...

Why a ‘soft landing’ might not solve Biden’s polling problem

Presented by NRF Foundation : Delivered daily by 8 a.m., Morning Money examines the latest news in finance politics and policy. Nov 29, 2023 View in browser   By Sam Sutton Presented by ...

New today: The #1 best selling mind-reading wallet of the year

"This is the best mentalism device I've seen in many years! Bar none." - Steven Palmer TL;DR:  Our most requested upgrade from pros. The best selling mind-reading wallet is now available for the first time in genuine leather for only $59.95 .  It's also available in a new color, midnight blue for only $39.95 We only have 150 genuine leather Razor Wallets, so they'll go fast. No more will arrive before Christmas. Genuine Leather Razor Wallet (only 150 available) https://www.penguinmagic.com/p/16650 ...

Playbook PM: Biden gets an eerie welcome to Pittsburgh

Presented by The American Beverage Association: POLITICO's must-read briefing on what's driving the afternoon in Washington. Jan 28, 2022 View in browser   By Garrett Ross and Eli Okun Presented by A two-lane bridge collapsed in Pittsburgh early Friday, prompting rescuers to rappel nearly 150 feet while others formed a human chain to help rescue multiple people from a dang...

"You won't find a card trick that is more fair." -Larry Hass

"I was hesitant when a neighbor threw me a deck and said show me something so I gave this a try, and blew them away more than once. " -Jim Carlough https://www.penguinmagic.com/p/13457 I love this trick. And I'll go through all the reason why. First, here's what happens: 1. Spectator shuffles a deck, then peaks at ANY card -- all in their own hands!!  2. The deck is then shuffled AGAIN, before you even look at the cards!! 3. Then, the spectator chooses (again a free choice) a random selection ...